Can Implant Abutments be Reused?

May 23, 2023

Leave a message

 

In dental practice, utilizing healing abutments repeatedly can be a cost-effective measure. However, it is crucial to note that abutments previously used and serviced by dental implant dealers may potentially lead to cross-infection. Therefore, as a cautious measure, these abutments should be thoroughly cleaned and sterilized before any reuse.

 

 Healing abutment (left) was placed in an Ultrasonic bath for ten minutes, then autoclaved. However, since proper cleaning was not achieved, sterilization was not possible. Compare this to a new healing abutment (right) and the difference is obvious

1. Healing abutments can only be used once.
The arguments against reuse of healing abutments are evident in the figure above. Regardless of the method used – steam or chemical autoclave, UV light or ethylene oxide – sterilization can never fully recreate the pristine surface of the original abutment.

 

2. Reuse of healing abutments marked for single use may seriously degrade product performance.
Sterilization using steam autoclaves, chemical autoclaves, lasers, or ethylene oxide may alter the composition of titanium surfaces, negatively affecting cells.

 

The physical surface topography alters the wettability of titanium, which interferes with the ability of epithelial cells and fibroblasts to attach and spread. This effect is completely different from that of a new (i.e. previously unused) healing abutment.

 

3. New threads are essential for consistently good results.
The threaded components of a healing abutment can also contain bioburden after removal and the threads are by far the most difficult part of a healing abutment to clean.

Healing abutment reuse

 

Although not in direct contact with the healing tissue, research has demonstrated that contamination and abrasion can affect the threads and potentially lead to internal damage to the implant.

 

Contamination can also cause the healing abutment to "lock" onto the implant. This is an extreme problem and has been known to cause the implant to be pulled out of the bone by reverse torque when attempting to unscrew the abutment.

 

4. The screwdriver may not properly engage the reusable healing abutment.


Debris that is very difficult to remove (callout 3) can jam the screwdriver insertion point. It should be noted that ultrasonic baths are unlikely to remove such tightly packed material. Additionally, with repeated use, mechanical damage may occur to the screw head itself.

 

Case reports in the literature indicate that this damage—unnecessary if you follow the manufacturer's single-use guidelines—can lead to problems with healing abutment retrieval.

Figure 3 (left). Debris often packs very tightly into the area of the screw head. Physical removal is often achieved at the expense of damage to the site. Figure 4 (right). Repeated use of the star driver has rounded the engaging part of the screw.

 

5. Mechanical cleaning of previously used abutments - especially through airborne particle abrasion - may damage the abutment/implant connection.


This reduces its sealing ability and alters component connections. Studies have also reported impregnation of abrasives into softer titanium, leading to metal contamination.

Figure 5. Scanning electron microscopy images of conical connection at 500x magnification (A – to the left). The effect of air particle abrasion cleaning on the fitting surface of an implant abutment is clearly evident (B – to the right). The implant-abutment interface with a new, clean abutment surface for comparison.

 

Potentially Costly Risk
Consider these five points carefully and you will see that the potential money savings from reusing the healing abutment a second time will not outweigh the known and potential health risks to the patient.

 

In short: To provide the patient with the greatest chance of soft tissue attachment, minimize inflammation and prevent possible recession - and give the bone a healthy start - always use clean, new healing abutments!

Send Inquiry